It’s not
often I return to blog subjects I’ve written about before but this one
particularly gauls me !
I was sat
watching BBC Question Time last week, on the panel was Labour MP Tristram Hunt,
he strikes me as one of the most unpleasant champagne socialists around. He’s
so obviously ‘posh’, he went to an exclusive private school in London and then
Cambridge University, indeed his father was Baron Hunt of Chesterton. I don’t suppose
there’s been many Labour MPs in its history called Tristram either. Labour is
supposed to be the party of the working class, so I thought, what on earth is
he doing as a member of its shadow cabinet?
I then began
to wonder how many more like him there are in the shadow cabinet of a party
that purports to represent us, the working class. How many had been to private
school, university, Oxbridge? How many had actually done a proper days work
rather than just left Uni’ and gone straight into politics via the researcher
route? So I did a bit of digging. The results should be surprising – but
they’re not !
Headed by Ed
Milliband, the Shadow Cabinet consists of 27 Labour MPs. Here’s what I found
about each of them :-
Ed Milliband Years employed in the ‘real world’ – ½
Educated at Comprehensive School then Oxford University
Experience - In 1992 he worked for a few months as a researcher for Channel 4 before being employed as a researcher by Harriet Harman.
Elected to Parliament in 1995
Harriet Harman Years employed in the ‘real world’ – 4
Educated at Private School then York University
Experience - Legal officer for the National Council for Civil Liberties for 4 years from 1978.
Elected to Parliament in 1982
Ed Balls Years employed in the ‘real world’ – 5
Educated at Private School then Oxford University
Experience - 1 year as a teaching fellow in the Department of Economics, Harvard University then 4 years as lead economic writer at the Financial Times. In 1994 he became an advisor to Gordon Brown.
Elected to Parliament in 2005
Douglas Alexander Years employed in the ‘real world’ – ½
Educated at Comprehensive School then Edinburgh University
Experience - Researcher for Gordon Brown in 1990 before returning for a second stint at university. He then worked for 6 months as a solicitor before entering politics full time.
Elected to Parliament in 1997
Yvette Cooper Years employed in the ‘real world’ – 2
Educated at Comprehensive School then Oxford University
Experience - Economic policy researcher to John Smith then Bill Clinton, then Harriet Harman. 1995-97, Chief economic correspondent of The Independent.
Elected to Parliament in 1997
Sadiq Khan Years employed in the ‘real world’ – 11
Educated at Comprehensive School then University of North London
Experience - Worked from 1994 - 2005 as a Human Rights Solicitor
Elected to Parliament in 2005
Rosie Winterton Years employed in the ‘real world’ – 4
Educated at Private School then University of Hull
Experience - John Prescott's Constituency PA from 1980 until 1986, then Parliamentary Officers, first for Southwark Council for two years until 1988 and then for a further two for the Royal College of Nursing until 1990. She followed this up with 4 years as Managing Director of Connect Public Affairs then back with Prescott as his advisor for 3 years.
Elected to Parliament in 1997
Andy Burnham Years employed in the ‘real world’ – 0
Educated at Comprehensive School then Cambridge University
Experience - Researcher to Tessa Jowell from 1994 until after the 1997 General Election. In 1998 he became a special advisor to the Secretary of State for Culture Media and Sport, Chris Smith, where he remained until his election to parliament
Elected to Parliament in 2001
Chuka Umunna Years employed in the ‘real world’ – 4
Educated at Private School then University of Manchester then Nottingham Law School
Experience - Worked as a Solicitor & political Writer from 2002 – 2006. Became Advisor to Labour’s John Cruddas in 2007, then adopted as Labour Party's prospective parliamentary candidate for Streatham
Elected to Parliament in 2010
Rachel Reeves Years employed in the ‘real world’ – 10
Educated at Comprehensive School then Oxford University then London School of Economics
Experience - Between 2000 and 2006 she was an economist at the Bank of England and British Embassy in Washington. Between 2006 and 2010 she worked for HBOS
Elected to Parliament in 2010
Tristram Hunt Years employed in the ‘real world’ – 5
Educated at Private School then Cambridge University
Experience - Part time historic Writer and broadcaster from 2001-2009 also working for Labour Party at same time
Elected to Parliament in 2010
Vernon Coaker Years employed in the ‘real world’ – 21
Educated at Grammar School then University of Warwick
Experience - Worked as a teacher from 1976 to 1997
Elected to Parliament in 1997
Hilary Benn Years employed in the ‘real world’ – 0
Educated at Comprehensive School then University of Sussex
Experience - Career before Parliament Research Officer with a trade union then various roles within Labour Party inc Special Adviser to David Blunkett.
Elected to Parliament in 1995
Caroline Flint Years employed in the ‘real world’ – 10
Educated at Comprehensive School then University of East Anglia
Experience - Worked for the Inner London Education Authority, 1984-87. The National Union of Students from 1988–89 and Lambeth Council 1989 – 1993. She was then the Senior Researcher and Political Officer for the GMB Union before entering Parliament.
Elected to Parliament in 1997
Angela Eagle Years employed in the ‘real world’ – 1
Educated at Comprehensive School then Oxford University
Experience - Worked for the CBI in 1984. Then went to work for COHSE (The Health Workers Union) until she entered Parliament
Elected to Parliament in 1992
Michael Dugher Years employed in the ‘real world’ – 1
Educated at Comprehensive School then University of Nottingham
Experience - Straight from University to be a Labour Party Advisor then Head of Policy at AEEU Union.
Elected to Parliament in 2010
Ivan Lewis Years employed in the ‘real world’ – 11
Educated at Private School then Bury College
Experience - Worked in the voluntary sector from 1986 to 1997 for Outreach
Elected to Parliament in 1997
Mary Creagh Years employed in the ‘real world’ – 10
Educated at Comprehensive School then Oxford University
Experience - 4 years working in Brussels first at the European Parliament, and then the European Youth Forum. She then worked at the London Enterprise Agency, a London-wide regeneration body
Elected to Parliament in 2005
Margaret Curran Years employed in the ‘real world’ – 18
Educated at Comprehensive School then University of Glasgow
Experience - Community worker and then a lecturer in community education at the University of Strathclyde. Previously elected to Scottish Parliament in 1999
Elected to Parliament in 2010
Owen Smith Years employed in the ‘real world’ – 15
Educated at Comprehensive School then University of Sussex
Experience - Did 5 years in the Biotechnology and Pharmaceuticals industry then 10 years as a radio producer. Followed by 3yrs as a Government Special Adviser
Elected to Parliament in 2010
Maria Eagle Years employed in the ‘real world’ – 7
Educated at Comprehensive School then Oxford University then College of Law, London
Experience - Worked as a solicitor from 1990 to 1997
Elected to Parliament in 1997
Lucy Powell Years employed in the ‘real world’ – 0
Educated - Comprehensive School then Oxford University then King's College London
Experience - Parliamentary assistant for Beverley Hughes MP in 1997. Worked for Government quango Britain in Europe (BiE) in a public relations role and later as their head of regional campaigning. Then worked for NESTA (the National Endowment for Science, Technology and the Arts) another quango. Finally worked for Ed Milliband before entering Parliament
Elected to Parliament in 2012
Jon Trickett Years employed in the ‘real world’ – 12
Educated at Grammar School
Experience - Outside of politics from 1974-86 he worked as a builder and plumber
Elected to Parliament in 1996
Gloria De Piero Years employed in the ‘real world’ – 13
Educated at Comprehensive School then University of Central England then University of Westminster then University of London
Experience - Journalism career from 1997 to 2010
Elected to Parliament in 2010
Chris Leslie Years employed in the ‘real world’ – 0
Educated at Grammar School then University of Leeds
Experience - Was a political research assistant from 1994 to 1997
Elected to Parliament in 1997
Baroness Royall Years employed in the ‘real world’ – 0
Educated at Grammar School then University of London
Experience - Special adviser to Neil Kinnock in the 1980s. In 2003 she became head of the European Union's office in Wales
Elected to Parliament, No! - House of Lords
Lord Bassam Years employed in the ‘real world’ – 9
Educated at Comprehensive School then University of Sussex then University of Kent
Experience - Social worker who moved on to other roles in local government after a period as an unemployed squatter.
Elected to Parliament, No - House of Lords
What Can We Ascertain From This?
The average number of years
worked outside of politics by the shadow cabinet is 6.4 years per member
Only 7 of the 27 members have
worked more than 10 years in a ‘proper’ job
The 8 most senior members of the
shadow cabinet have a total of 27 years in a proper job between them (I’ve got
more than that !!!)
Only one member has done a truly “working
class” job, that being Jon Trickett who was a builder and plumber
A third (9) of the 27 shadow
cabinet members have done a year or less of work outside of politics
All the shadow cabinet (with the
exception of Ivan Lewis and Jon Trickett) have been to University
Despite Labour constantly
attacking the Tories as being a bunch of posh OxBridge toffs, 10 of the shadow
cabinet went to Oxford or Cambridge
6 members of the shadow cabinet
went to private school, with a further 4 going to Grammar school.
7 members of the shadow cabinet only
entered Parliament in 2010 or later, highlighting their inexperience. This proportion
of junior MPs in a cabinet is almost unheard of.
Outside of education, law, quangos and journalism not a single one of them has run a business. If they do win the election, how on earth can they generate growth in the UK when none of them has any business experience, they don't understand business, because of this they have no sympathy for business and will therefore fail to gain the support of business. Don't forget business isn't just the corporate multi-nationals, its the small self-employed business' that are run on a shoe string. Labour proved their lack of understanding and sympathy for these small business' with their recent announcement that they'd extend paternity leave if they got in.
The bigger issue is that more than two thirds of
the Labour shadow cabinet easily qualify as career politicians. What wisdom and
experience of the world can we expect them to bring to the UK if they get
elected in May? Answer – None, because they have none themselves.
People will still continually blindly vote for
Labour though. It seems they have lost the ability to think for themselves, they
basically think, daddy voted labour so I have to vote labour. A committed
Labour voter would keep on voting for a skunk if it had a red rosette tied to
its tail!
The Age of the Career Politician
One in seven MPs has never had a
proper job. Many more have worked only briefly as lobbyists, speech writers or
PR advisers. Of course, lots of good people go into politics with a desire to
benefit society. But career politicians have gradually changed the makeup of
the House of Commons and diminished the standing of Parliament. Career
politicians can’t empathise with the lives of the electorate because they don’t
know about ordinary working life. Their engagement feels false and undermines
trust.
How can someone go from school to university then
into politics and expect to have a rounded view of life? They drift along
within the cloistered & dreaming spires of academia before being
"picked up" and parachuted into the Westminster bubble without ever
having to earn a penny by their own wits or the sweat of their brow.
Andrew Marr – Right For Once
Andrew
Marr, the former BBC Political Reporter did an interview last year where he
stated that “Aspiring politicians should
not be allowed to become MPs until they are 40”, He said politicians should
have to ‘do something first’ to
tackle a lack of ‘gritty real-world experience’
in the House of Commons. The broadcaster pointed out that MPs used to spend
years in different careers first. Many had ‘built
their own companies and knew the inside out of a balance sheet’.
He stated “When I started out politics reporting,
there were still Tories who had had a good war, built their own companies, had
really good experience, knew the inside out of a balance sheet, had employed
and sat and worried about profits. On the Labour side you had ex-miners, metal
workers, ex-factory hands, ex-posties. So there were people all over the House
of Commons who had done other things first and that really mattered. We’ve lost most of that gritty,
real-world experience in the House of Commons”.
For a change - I can’t help agree with him! But, in
addition to being over 40, they need to have done something sensible and
constructive in life and gained some relevant experience by it, they need to
have some links with the constituency they wish to represent, and they need to
be vetted to make sure they aren't going to be an embarrassment, (eg drug
taking or breaking the law in any other way, having dodgy financial or sexual
practices), in other words they should be checked out to make sure they are
decent, upstanding members of society. I know this is stating the bleeding
obvious but the bleeding obvious seems to have disappeared in today's world. Oh
and another thing, ministerial appointees should be required to have prior
detailed knowledge of their brief rather than their face fitting or as a favour
for services rendered !!
Sea Change Needed
Every elected official not just MP's should
have non-political jobs in industry or society before being allowed to stand. A
minimum of 10 years in real jobs working for commercial companies or indeed
being successfully self employed should be mandatory. We need real people with
the right qualities to solve the real problems we have in this country. This work/life
experience must not be politics related, no lobbyists, no researchers, etc
It should be that you have a minimum of 10 years
of this ‘real work’ before your name can appear as a candidate for MP, along with
strict limits on the amount of money and time for ‘additional’ work outwith MP
duties once you get there - and, if legally possible, some way to help curtail
those directorships MPs walk into after they leave due to "having helped out" while they were in power. And don't
anyone say "no one would want to be
an MP with such restrictions", Really? There are millions of dedicated
volunteers working for other people for literally nothing up and down the
country? I’m sure they’d happily stand. The people who would make the best
politicians are those who would not dream of going round pontificating about
what other people should do.
We should also require that prospective MPs are
resident in their constituency for perhaps 5 or 10 years before standing for
election. No more parachuting the great and worthy into safe seats as a reward
for being a compliant party lackey.
Changing the name would be a big call too,
say ‘MP’ to ‘RP’ as in Representative of the People. The role shouldn't sound
like a member of an exclusive club.
Wisdom
Needed
If you were designing a democratic Country from
scratch the last thing you would come up with is what we have now. This isn't just a Labour Party issue, it's across all three main parties. Politics is
seen as a career these days, and the way to climb up the career ladder is to
basically lick the arse of the leadership. Do we really want this? I know I don’t!
Wisdom comes from experience and age. Another
thing we have is too many MPs who are too young and show absolutely no common
sense. Over the years the age of Prime Ministers has come down and it is quite
obvious by the way this country is declining rapidly that they lack experience,
authority and judgement. Parliament is full of immature airheads who have the
responsibility to run this country and in political terms they can't even tie
their own laces.
Office managers is what we get at the moment,
not Statesmen or Stateswomen, We need wise people that know how the population
has to live much more than how the political system works to make the laws we
have to live under.
We need wise people who know what is happening in
the real world to run the country. We need politicians of conviction not idiots
who are making a career out of it. - They should get some life experience of
their own before they tell us how to live ours.
.....Oh and if we were to require their IQ to be above 40 as well, we
might stand a chance of getting a half decent Government one day.